So You Think
If a Cox Plate was won on looks alone, So You Think would win by the length of The Valley straight. A striking bay colt that sometimes appeared almost black with a long flowing dark mane, So You Think stamped himself as a champion at just his fifth start when the Bart Cummings trained three-year-old took out the 2009 W.S. Cox Plate with Glen Boss onboard.
The son of High Chaparral had won two of his first four starts and the debate raged in the lead-up as to whether his form warranted a place in the W.S. Cox Plate field, with the Committee deciding he was worth the gamble. History suggests they were more than vindicated.
In a slick time of 2:03:98, Glen Boss didn’t give his competitors a chance in the race with a front-running victory by two and half lengths, with race caller Greg Miles rightfully claiming “Bart’s done it again” with the champion trainer’s fourth win in the race that had included Dane Ripper (1997), Saintly (1996) and Taj Rossi (1973). It was also owner Dato Tan Chin Nam’s second Cox Plate victory following Saintly’s win.
So You Think returned 12 months later and at just his tenth start he started one of the shortest priced favourites in the race’s history. This time Steven Arnold took the ride and it while he opted to take a sit on More Joyous rather than lead throughout, the then four-year-old was never troubled and won with ease. Jockey Steven Arnold joked that he thought So You Think was so special he used to wipe his feet before he got onto the horse.
Cummings’ track rider Joe Agresta also paid a special tribute to So You Think, saying that apart from being a champion, such was his status, that he was a “horse of a generation”. Foreman Reg Fleming also had an emotional response when quizzed on his opinion of the stallion… “You want to know how special he is? If I’m having a bad day, I’ll go in his box with him, after that, I’m having a good day!”
So You Think’s stunning second victory in 2010 had now put him on par with the feats of champions like Phar Lap, Tobin Bronze, Sunline and Northerly as a dual winner of Australia’s greatest weight-for-age race. While Cummings was a genius trainer, he was never overly forthcoming with his praise given he trained so many superstars, but did offer this on So You Think. “It takes a special horse to win a Cox Plate, it takes a great horse to win two.”
The question remains, how many Cox Plates could So You Think have won had he stayed in Australia? Having been sold to Coolmore for a princely sum reported to be around $30M and more, he was sent to Aidan O’Brien and would go on to win five international Group 1 races including the Irish Champion Stakes and Prince of Wales’s Stakes.
So You Think entered the Australian Racing Hall of Fame in 2019 and currently serves as a shuttle stallion in both the Southern and Northern Hemispheres for Coolmore Stud, having sired six individual Group 1 winners with many more to come.
Phar Lap
Ask any non-racing folk who are some of the famous racehorses they know, and Phar Lap is often the one that springs to mind.
Even some 90 years after his heroic reign as Australia’s best horse, his story continues to be passed on from generation to generation, and you will do well to find someone who hasn’t stumbled across his name at some point in time.
Phar Lap was a burly New Zealand-bred chestnut who for obvious reasons adopted the nickname “Big Red.” A gelding who came from humble beginnings as a cheap purchase, Phar Lap was a key driver for motivation and hope during the Great Depression as he often defied the realms of possibility and gave Australians great happiness in times of hardship.
A dual Cox Plate Champion amongst many other accolades, Phar Lap was adored by fans but understandably envied by his opposition. Despite this, he wasn’t always the dominant force he eventually became.
In fact, it took Phar Lap five starts to break his maiden as a two-year-old and a further five starts to win again as a three-year-old, and at that point his measly price tag of 160 guineas probably would have seemed justified.
But, from there, he was close to unbeatable. He won 18 of his next 21 starts, including wins in the Rosehill Guineas, AJC Derby, Craven Plate twice, VRC St Leger and the VRC Derby, where he defeated the high-priced colt Carradale owned by VRC Chairman L.K.S Mackinnon, prompting Mackinnon to ban geldings from competing in the classic moving forward.
Such was Phar Lap’s dominance that many, including authorities, took it upon themselves to change rules to get him beaten or try and prevent him from running, a common theme throughout his career and one that saw him the centre of controversy when withdrawn from races or when carrying monstrous weights in the handicaps he contested.
Unfortunately for those who rivalled him, these monstrous weights weren’t feasible at weight-for-age level in the W.S. Cox Plate, and so in 1930 he came to The Valley as the 1/7 favourite, and duly saluted, running away a four-length victor and untested by his rider Jim Pike.
Expected to win, his Cox Plate success was hardly newsworthy for the press. Phar Lap was only news when he was beaten or when he was the subject of drama. As was the case when he was controversially scratched from the Caulfield Cup by his trainer Harry Telford, or when he was later shot at by gangsters who deemed that the only way possible to deny him from an inevitable Melbourne Cup win.
Much to the heroics of his beloved strapper Tommy Woodcock, who shielded Phar Lap from the gunfire and got him to safety, Big Red and Woodcock survived.
Not only did he survive, but he got better on the track. He further extended his winning streak coming into his five-year-old season, before tasting defeat, only losing once when badly underdone. He went into the 1931 Cox Plate as an even shorter priced favourite than the year before, this time at 1/14.
Unbackable by the average punter, Phar Lap still had support from the high-end stake punters, with one keen backer happy to outlay 200 pounds just to profit 16. Phar Lap didn’t let them down, streaking away for another effortless two-and-a-half length victory after coasting to the lead approaching the turn.
After the 1931 Cox Plate, Phar Lap only raced three more times, winning his second Mackinnon Stakes, carrying an impossible 70.5kg in the Melbourne Cup where he could only manage eighth, and a final famous victory in Mexico in the Agua Caliente Handicap.
Six days later he tragically passed away, in circumstances which are still a mystery. Whether he was intentionally or unintentionally poisoned remains unknown, but what we do know is that he is to this day one of the greatest horses in Australian racing history, and his name will forever be one of the most famous on the W.S. Cox Plate honour roll.